Men of Legacy

May 2025 marks the 1-year anniversary of the opening of the Eichelberger Distillery. The distillery was completed in 2024 after many years of delays, disappointments, and changes of direction. Finally, dreams became reality as we legally fired-up the handmade copper stills and whiskey began to flow. Unfortunately, not all who were instrumental in bringing the vision to life lived to experience whiskey being made as it was in the 18th century.

The Impractical Distillers navigated the circuitous path to producing authentic 18th century whiskey without compasses or catalogues and few colleagues for collaboration. But they weren’t alone. Four men helped set the course, championed the vision and deserve a toast with a hearty pour of Monaghan Rye.

Larry Klase was an indomitable force. He never lost hope. While soliciting donations with a coffee can in front of the tavern he encountered another history lover.  Charlie Vogelsong  embraced NYCHAPS’  vision to preserve and promote local history and provided substantial funding to restore the tavern and relocate  an 18th century German barn to the site. Larry served as president of NYCHAPS for several terms. He and his wife Joanne initiated First Fridays at Dills Tavern. His admonition to "Keep Smiling" became lasting advice.

George Platts was a philosopher-blacksmith. George  was an enthusiastic representative of Dills Tavern who recruited many of the docents and volunteers who still contribute to NYCHAPS. His knowledge of the French and Indian War, York County’s participation in the Revolutionary War, and native culture was unsurpassed.  He often showed up barefooted to events.

Many of the plans for the distillery were hatched during fireside chats at the cabin he built in the woods. His metal working skills helped us build the copper stills we use.

Mark Hagenbuch traveled the world participating in a variety of re-enactments. His portrayals include a Highlander, Civil War soldier from the Stone Wall Brigade, German farmer, and British soldier at Waterloo. Mark was a former multi-term NYCHAPS president and recruited many historical societies and re-enactment groups to visit and utilize Dills Tavern for programs and events. Unmatched as a fundraiser, he acquired donations in excess of of $500,000 to build the distillery. Dr. Hagenbuch retired as an elementary school principal. His passion for kids’ programs was equal to his love of a dram by the fire.

Steve Pancoe had an infectious personality. He portrayed Colonel William Clapham, who built forts in Pennsylvania during the French and Indian War. His extensive collection of firearms, accoutrements, books, and period clothing were displayed at many events. Steve was an avid ambassador whose colorful portrayals and personality drew visitors and volunteers to NYCHAPS.

The legacy of these men endures and their faces watch over daily labors in the distillery. Larry, Mark, George, and Steve’s vision, commitment, and never-ending belief that a small community historical society can achieve big things lives on. Please visit the Eichelberger Distillery where we share their stories, our whiskey and a passion for history. We raise a glass of Monaghan Rye to these fine gentlemen. May they rest in peace.

~The Impractical Distillers:  Sam and Murray